Should i give positive or neutral feedback on an online purchase?

I ordered a "collector's set" of the carol burnett show from ioffer.com with 91 episodes for my mom for xmas. Here is the description:





(All DVD Sets Come in Full DVD Cases with Professional Artwork. All Sets are Sealed for Gift Quality. The Carol Burnett Show aka Carol Burnett %26amp; Friends : The Carol Burnett Show is a sketch comedy television show starring Carol Burnett , Tim Conway , Harvey Korman , Vicki Lawrence , and Lyle Waggoner . It originally ran on CBS from September 11, 1967 to March 29, 1978


8 DVD Set


Out of Print Movies and TV Series Transferred to DVD.


All Movies have been transferred to DVD-R for customers that want a more affordable and easier way to view these hard to find classics.


The Movies have been Tested and are Guaranteed for First Class Video Playback.


We only use the highest quality products for all of out transfers. We replace any defective DVD鈥橲.


All DVD鈥橲 Are Region Free and will work on all DVD Players.)





Item arrived with fast shipping, however, all 8 dvds were just stacked on eachother in 1 dvd case. They had plain white labels with no writing on them, and I have reason to believe the episodes were edited only to contain the sketches (The show also had musical numbers and q-and-a segments.) The sketches are all i really cared about but I have to wonder if anything else was edited out since the episodes are supposed to be 54 min. and these are like 22 min.





The product was worth the 18.98 for this many hours of good show in my opinion, but should i leave positive or neutral feedback??????|||Neither - You should leave negative feedback. The items do not MATCH the item description. They may have notes of similarity, but definitely do not match. And the way they were shipped could have cause damage to the disks for all they know. Be honest and leave a negative.|||Well, I get the impression that you received pirated copies of what you ordered. DO you think that is possible, or do you think they really were simply copies of a master DVD that were edited?





Hard to advise you on this.|||Your description sounds like that of a pirated product. Then again, you did only pay $18.98 for it.